From:-
Gunvant R.Parikh
B.E.Civil, LL.B.
Hon Adm.Officer. VKK>
Consumer affairs & Executive Engineer R&B (Retd,)
4- Mangal Park, B/H post office
Geetamandir road
Ahmedabad 22 (380022 )
T.Nos. 077925324676 ,9408294609 ,9924433362
To
Election commissioner (chief()
Election commission
Nirvachan Bhavan
New-Delhi
SubL- Sanction to new political parties ..........
Dear sir ,
It is so learnt that under the constitutionl provisions Election commission is enpowered to sanction any new political party. .Of course I don't know the criteria to sanction the party so that they can contest the assembly or loksabha election. But what I have observed is somewhat serious and it requires your prompt attention.
At present there are number of political parties on the screen of Indian Politics. May be they are placing some fulfillments of your criteris but actually they won't deserve to contest election and to represent the public as there is no public interest but only personal interest or personal ego.
I would like to draw your attention to newly created political party in Gujarat Viz. PARIVARTAN PARTY . May be they have fulfilled yourb criteria but not fulfilled the concept of the public or requirements of the public of GUjarat. Actually what is observed by the public of Gujarat is that theall most all the members of the party are dissatisfied elemens of some existing party under which they were registerd i.e. they are the members of existing BJP party of National level. . May be they have some dispute with existing party but it won't allow them to create anew party at state level and to disturb the politis of State. Principally or ethically there is no reason with them to create new party. It is the image of the public of Gujarat that the only aim they have got is to remove the present CHief Minister. There are constitutional means and ways to remove their leader. but only the revenge is not the criteria. Gujarat remembers the past when the present leader of new political parivartan party was removed by their own party members. Twice it happened and as a result the members dissatisfied had intended to create new party.As proclaimed by them they want to bring PARIVARTAN . But what type of parivartan ? Just to change the leader or just to change Chief MInister ? By their seperation whether the Parivartan party will win the election and will they seure majority to form the governmant ? No, not possible , There is one another national party also in Gujarat i.e. CONGRESS Party. All these three parties will break the harmony of the state and it may be that none out of these three parties can get absolute majority. Ultimately gujarat will have to suffer. There will not be steady government. There will be politics of combinations of parties and defactorship policy will rule. Elected mem,bers will have their own market vaue instead of their public representative..There will be tug of war to win the majority at the cost of stability of the state.
This is the time when ELECTION COMMISSION must be serious to view the picture of politics.
I would like to suggest to allow only two parties in state as well as in centre. One must be ruling party and another the opposition. More to more you can allow individuals if found suitable with certain terms and conditions. Particularly if they want to join any side they should resign first from the house and then to contest again under the shield of other party. .Once el4ected person should not be allowed to join another parety nor allow to vote against their party whip and direction. The same procedure must be implimented for the election of the loksabha also. There must not more than two parties. All other regional parties must be directed either to join ruling party or to join opposition party. .If they are satisfied with ruling party then to support rulers or oppose them under opposition party. In this way there will be strong opposition who can give successful role of opposition and better contro the ruling party. .The present situation is such critical that none of the parties are having clear majority and alliances gives trouble to the nation and its securuty as well adminustration also.Ruling party remains always under tension to maintain the majoriyty in the house and for this purpose it has to surrender before allied parties. In many cases they have to undergo the blackmailing of allied parties and allied parties are taking extreme disadvantages at the risk and cost of ruling party as well nation and public interest also. You can study the case of present prime minister of ruling UPA govt. that he has to surrender before three queens i.e Mamataji,Mayaji and Jailalitaji and also from others regional party members of elected loksabha members.There should not be any existense of regional parties in centre i.e. loksabha Either they must contest under the flag of ruling party or under the flag of opposition no other choice. . And now in such circumstances there will be no chance or question of clear majoruty. At least one party will get clesr majority and they will be the ruling party.
This standard must be observed for state and centre elections. All dissatisfied elements must not allow to create new party to disturb the stability of the government. .What is the idea and principle to allow anew MJP under Gordhanbhai Zadfia at Gujarat and what is their aim? Just to apture chair or just to throw away their unwanted CM ? Same is the question repeated in creation of GPP Gujarat Parivartan Party, What is their aim and priniples ? Just to remove present CM is the only goal . But by this way they are disturbing the present govrrtnment and also disturb stability of administration of Gujarat Governmenrt as such there will be no clear majority of any party/ These two newly created and seperated parties will disturbe present ruling party and also they will distub present opposiotion party also. .If opposition party can be stronger they can cbe ruling party also but in case of unstabilitu and lack of clear majority none out of these three or four parties can be ruler and in in that case alliance will ruin the administration and aayaram gayaram will be promoted. at the risk and cost of public and state.
If found suitable a special ordinance may be declared just in the way like special ordinance of emergency declared in past. All the elected members must be compelled either to join ruling party and support their proclamation or to select opposition party to control the rulers. This proposal can be proposed only by the chief election commission being autonomous body. Election commission is not working under any government and not under the control of executives. They may take advice and directions or support of suprem court. They can invite public debate on the subject matter issue..
Waiting for your response,,reply and opinion on the subject issue please.
Yours faithfully
G.R.Parikh.
Hon.Adm Officer
To
CEO
Gujarat
Sachivalaya Gandhinagar :-
Dear Madam,
I have pasted the copy of letter addressed to chief election Officer Election Commission , Nirvachan Bhavan New Delhi for your ready reference to consider the facts and for for your strong recommendation please.
If you want steady Government either at state level or central level , no doubt healthu competition must be there but in no way such numbers of parties contesting election . There must not be more than two parties to contest the election to rule. : one ruling party and another opposition ., both at state level as well central level. If National parties has no weightage at state level i.e. at regional level , they can contest the election at state level under the shield of regional level but at at central level they must select ither to support ruling party or to opposition. They should not be given any chance to topple the government at frequent warnings and threats to the ruling party. to damage the steady Government. They may be given full chance to form and frame Government by obtaining majorit in the house but in no way there should be business of defacto policy of changing the parties at frequent occasion. This ccontrol can be enforced by only Election Commission . It is an individual body , beyond the control of government to frame policy decision.If there is some hitch in implementation of this process , it must be solved by the competant forces, competant authorities , no question if political parties are also included in the debate and discussion but there must be only two parties. At present you can easily understand the position of centra Government where they have no absolute majority and as such they have to rely upon the regional parties and all such parties are blackmailing the central Govt. ad extracting what they desire from the govt. to support at the time of voting in the house. UPA govt. cannot take srttrong decision only because of this mix combnation of various parties. . In such case each member who is individual or of a regional party create their big value to encash their vote. either in terms of cash, kind or post or by any such advantage. . I think , I believe also , that the Administrative cadre is not so weak that the temp. persons can rule over them. . Election commiission is beyond the watch of Govewrnment and parliament also upto certain extent. Judiciary is there to control the abuse decision of commission if so they found,which they had found at Gujarat to check the soueces of money , and still the doors are open for commission to go to supreme court. Constitution has given ample powers to election commission , The officers are from Administrative services, foreign services or whichevr may be the source , at least there are supposed to be intelligent and efficient enough to control the situation.
Dear Mdam , may be tomorrow you can also be Chief Election commissioner, as per seniority intelligence and efficiency ... At present as afar as Gujarat Election is concerned, the situation is enough fluid. There are two major National parties and they may be allowed to create competition but if some dissatisfied elements from one party desires to seperate party, there will be three to four such contestant to compete. The result may be such , none may get absolute majority . What weill be tjhe situation of Governmant >? House will be a trading zone to pull the votes to create majority. Is there any policy ? No....not the list . . BJP is threatened by parivartan party which originaly was BJP in the same way NCP is also a part of National party , Congress and also a partner at cewntral level with congress. Suppose NCP and congress are jointly give the fight , but what about their individual existence ? There is no policy existence simply connected each other to capture the chair and rule the Government. Election commission has no control over such parties giving bogus promises to public. Proclamation is authentic but promises are not authentic and in no way public must be misgiided with such temptations under bogus promises. Election commission can keep red eyes towards such situation. Just imagine in one movie Shree 420 there was a proclaimed promise to attract public to provide a residence in just Rs. 100 / - to pay and crores of rupees were collected on that name , today also number of such cheaters are collecting money from public in the name of ek ka teen , and such other promises to provide residence, plot , laptop , etc.etc. but is ther any clarification that from which spource they are to give such facilities ? They have not to pay any thing from their own pocket. How Government can afford such lahani distribution ? some body says they will provide rice at 2/- per kg. and some says they will give wheat at 3/- per kg. and they are collectuing the grains and not even manage the collected grains till it is deteriorated and destroyed . .Only Election Commission can control the root cause of the evil .
Dear Madam , I know you are duty bound with the Chief Election Commission , you have your own limitations , may be under pressure of present work load of forthcoming state assembly election but at least you can forward this submission to election commission at central level with your opinipon or at least may guide to submit my facts at which level and with which approach. I am worring , wat weill be thje position of aGovernment if there will not be absolute majoruty of any single party ? There may be chaos or in constitutyional way there will be president rule . But in all the cases the administration will be in the hands of administrative officers. They can control in the way they desire what I feel and believe..
Hoping for the response and reply
Thanks ,
Yours faith fully
G.R.Parikh
11-11-12
No comments:
Post a Comment